Pizzeta Pizza Millburn, NJ

4/ 8
Slice Rating

Pizzeta Pizza Millburn, NJ

Posted By: Pizza Expert
View site

pizzeta.jpgMy wife was nice enough to bring this pizza to me while I was filming in Springfield.  She also brought me pizza from Semolina pizza, but we will review that in the near future.  Pizzeta was one of the two places we noticed in Milburn, while checking out the town. It seemed nice from the outside and I wanted to go in myself, but I had to be at my taping within 10 minutes of our drive, and I didn't want to take the chance.

When my wife dropped off the pie, it looked pretty good.  I couldn't wait to take a bite, but I figured it would be rude to eat without sharing with the others.  When I finally got the opportunity to taste the pie, I wasn't blown away.  It tasted average, but I had much higher hopes for the pizza.  It is completely unfair to say anything else bad about this pizza, since it was delivered in a cardboard box, and sat for about 7 more minutes before we got to eat it.

What I tasted was adequate.  It seems like this place had the potential to taste good hot and out of the oven. The cheese still tasted fresh, but the sauce was not really to my liking.  The crust was full of flour, and really didn't taste anything special.  The pie at this point was pretty much soggy since I waited so long.

Although I seldom get up to Millburn, NJ, if I ever do, I will be sure to try the pie hot, and give it another review. If you happen to live nearby and could provide me with your own review of Pizzeta Pizza, I would appreciate it, since it appears this place could be much better then I might suppose.

For now Pizzeta gets 4 out of 8 slices.

  • make an
    (973) 376-3773

  • 44 Main St Millburn, NJ 07041-1360