Costello’s Pizza Jupiter, FL

4/ 8
Slice Rating

Costello’s Pizza Jupiter, FL

Posted By: CS
View site

My wife and I never really eat at the pizza place in our Abacoa neighborhood named Costello's, to us it’s an after thought but last night we were coming home late and wanted a bite, so we went to eat there and try it out.

We ordered a large plain pizza pie and brought it home got out the plates and each grabbed a slice. On first bite it was thick with a hint of spice, my wife said “there was too much oregano in the sauce”. To me the crust was somewhat dry and the flavor overbearing.

As a fan of pizza, there’s no such thing as a bad slice just some that far exceed others. This slice fell somewhere in the low range of potential favorites. The big question would I go back? Depends, do I feel like driving.

Costello's Pizza in Jupiter gets 4 out of 8 slices.

Costello's Trattoria & Pizzeria on Urbanspoon

  • make an
    (561) 776-5448

  • 1209 Main St # 102 Jupiter, FL 33458

Leave a Reply

  • *
  • *

2 Responses to “Costello’s Pizza Jupiter, FL”

  • Bjfpremierepoolsvc wrote:
    25 Dec 2011 at 12:57 pm

    I am from new York and snow bird for three months in fl. Back home I eat pizza four times a week. I have tried at least fourty pizzaria’s In Florida and nothing even comes close to Costello’s! Its just like home. They use grande cheese even though it is twice the price. People that wouldn’t like this place are probably not used to good ny pizza! No question its the best around!!

  • abacoa tom wrote:
    12 Jul 2013 at 5:55 pm

    You sound like a crybaby