review

Mama Lombardi’s Pizza Islip Macarthur Airport

Well sadly the day arrived where I must bid farewell to two of the things I love most in my life in new York.  My family who would rather freeze then move to florida and New York Pizza!  Since my family reads my reviews I am kind of obligated to say that I of course […]

5 / 8
Slice Rating

Mama Lombardi’s Pizza Islip Macarthur Airport

Posted By: Pizza Expert
View site

Well sadly the day arrived where I must bid farewell to two of the things I love most in my life in new York.  My family who would rather freeze then move to florida and New York Pizza!  Since my family reads my reviews I am kind of obligated to say that I of course love my family more than the pizza.
We prefer to fly out of Long Island Macarthur Airport since it is much easier to navigate through compared to LaGuardia and JFK. Plus Southwest flies there and they are usually much better then Crappy airlines like Spirit Airlines. Worstpizza certainly does not recommend Spirit Air. Actually maybe I should start worstairlines.com to discuss my awful experiences with them. It becomes quite evident after flying with Spirit why they offer $9 fares. I would rather spend more and fly Southwest. This has nothing to do with pizza so I will stop there.
Macarthur airport even has a full service pizza place there called Mama Lombardi’s!! Yes no terrible sbarro’s at this airport. They have true pizza that tastes like actual pizza. I ordered a regular slice to eat, but you can find an amazing variety of different kinds of pizza here, with numerous toppings to choose from.
My slice tasted better than any airport pizza I ever ate. Sure it was $3.39 a slice, but given the fact that they could charge over $4 like some of their shitty competitors would, it seemed like a decent price to charge for the quality of pie they are producing, at the rent they are paying.
The slice was thrown into the pizza oven and soon after I paid, it came out.  If it weren’t for the airplanes outside, I would have no idea I was eating airport pizza.  The crust was crisp and tasty.  The cheese was of a top quality, and the sauce was sweet and applied pretty evenly.  I would have even gotten a second slice, if they hadn’t started boarding our plane!
Mama Lombardi’s Pizza gets 5 out of 8 slices.

  • make an
    order

  • 100 Arrivals Avenue, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

Leave a Reply

  • *
  • *

5 Responses to “Mama Lombardi’s Pizza Islip Macarthur Airport”

  • uberVU - social comments wrote:
    05 Jan 2010 at 10:14 am

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by Lapp: RT @tweetmeme Mama Lombardi’s Pizza Islip Macarthur Airport | worstpizza.com – Best Pizza Reviews Pizza Jobs Pizza P… http://bit.ly/8GwgdD

  • […] Mama Lombardi’s Pizza Islip Macarthur Airport | worstpizza.com – Best Pizza Reviews Pizza Jobs Pizza Place For Sale By craigagranoff Well sadly the day arrived where I must bid farewell to two of the things I love most in my life in new York.  My family who would rather freeze then move to florida and New York Pizza!  Since my family reads my reviews I am kind of obligated to say that I of course live my family more than the pizza. We prefer to fly out of Long Island Macarthur Airport since it is much easier to navigate through compared to LaGuardia and JFK. Plus Southwest flies there and they are usually much better then Crappy airlines like Spirit Airlines. Worstpizza certainly does not recommend Spirit Air. Actually maybe I should start worstairlines.com to discuss my awful experiences with them. It becomes quite evident after flying with Spirit why they offer $9 fares. I would rather spend more and fly Southwest. This has nothing to do with pizza so I will stop there. via worstpizza.com […]

  • Matt wrote:
    18 Jan 2011 at 3:24 am

    Hungry and in desperation to get one last slice of authentic New York pizza before heading back to the South, wife and I ate here today befoe getting on the plane and the cheese slices were surprisngly really good! My expectations from an airport pizza place were not high, but I’ll definitely hit this place if our travels ever bring us to MacArthur Airport again.

  • Craig (lapp) wrote:
    18 Jan 2011 at 3:27 am

    I couldn’t agree with you more. I usually grab a slice here each and every time I am at the airport. It amazes me that they are still cheaper per slice, then some Boca Raton pizzerias, and they have to pay airport rent!

  • Matt wrote:
    21 Jan 2011 at 3:40 am

    Our first stop for pizza when we arrived in Long Island was Gino’s (in Islip) at a friend’s recommendation and it was fabulous. Silician slice was amazing! Next time I’ll grab the first slice right there at Mamma’s and then head to Gino’s. Another noteworthy slice was at Mario’s in Plainview.

RECEIVE PIZZA REVIEWS