Matt’s Pizza St. James New York

1/ 8
Slice Rating

Matt’s Pizza St. James New York

Posted By: Pizza Expert
View site

matsspizza.jpgmatts.jpgMy father and I stopped at Matt's Pizza in St. James. I have never been to Matt's but my dad has ordered from them in the past, and suggested I at least give it a shot. Upon walking into Matt's, I couldn't help but notice how dirty the place was.

Even though it wasn't too busy, it took forever for them to serve me, and after looking at how stale and old the pizza looked, I decided it was best to just walk out and not try their pizza this day.

Matt, you really need to clean up the place after people eat, and be more attentive at the counter. Not as attentive as Patio Pizza, since they didn't even let me look, but you need to teach your employees how to acknowledge potential customers. You should also consider displaying your pizza in a more appetizing way. Most looked stale and appeared to have been sitting there for a while.

Matt, I will definitely be back to at least try your pizza, since there is nothing positive or negative I could say about it as of now, but after reading some of the other reviews online, it makes me skeptical that people consider this the best. Rocco's in St. James has been "the best" so far in my opinion, and you will have big shoes to fill in order to beat their sicilian.

  • make an
    (631) 862-6161

  • 348 Lake Avenue St James, NY 11780

Leave a Reply

  • *
  • *

4 Responses to “Matt’s Pizza St. James New York”

  • st james diner wrote:
    16 Jan 2010 at 6:05 pm

    Matts is the cheapo of pizza. I liked the rust but where was the cheese? And for the toppings… I orders a meatball and a susage. Both looked the same. Looked like rabbit pellets onto of the pizza.
    You get what you pay for. As patio is good. wow way over priced

  • Ken wrote:
    29 Apr 2010 at 4:48 pm

    Matt's sucks! Really, don't like it at all… That's where all the High School dropouts hang out next to the smoke shop… Head on down the road to Caliguiri's Patio Pizza to get a great slice!

  • Mojorisin7178 wrote:
    30 Mar 2011 at 1:24 am

    Matts pizza is not that bad actually pretty good. But as for sanitation now there is a problem lets just say they might have a bit of a rodent problem there. As for patio well overpriced is not the word and their pizza sucks their dinners suck the owners are cocky and they get an all around F. Roccos pizza is where its at. Not quite as good as matts but still very good and not dirty and way better than Patio.

  • Bungabunga wrote:
    05 Jun 2011 at 4:28 am

    Why so negative? Do you even like pizza?  Matt’s is excellent.  Next time you’re up in NY, where real pizza comes from, try a slice.