John’s Pizza Bleeker Street NYC
April 11th, 2009 - By: Matt's Pizza
John’s Pizza on Bleeker street in NYC is rightfully famous. It’s story is the story of pizza in New York, and therefore the United States. However, I have long ago given up on their pizza in favor of some, in my opinion, better places.
Now that I write for Worst Pizza I decided to take Mrs. Pizza on a pizza history tour of New York, and decided to once again try John’s. It must have been 15 years since stepping foot in the place, but it looked the same. Upon my first bite, I remember why I had stopped coming here. Tasteless. The crust was just tasteless. Their cheese was decent, but the sauce wasn’t anything that could possibly propel them to the top. I have once heard John’s reduced to the best pizza in the Village, but no, there are better. Much better. Don’t believe the hype. John’s gets 3 of 8 slices.
Related Post
John’s Pizza Bleeker Street NYC
Address |
260 W 44th St New York, NY 10036 |
Phone |
(212) 243-1680 |
Website |
www.johnspizzerianyc.com |













I disagree with you 100%. I give it 8 of 8 slices! The place is famous and rightfully so as you said, they must be doing something right being that they have been around since 1929! And it is always packed. I live in the area and constantly frequent the place. Its the best pizza in New York! And by the way, you spelled Bleecker wrong!!!
I disagree with you 100%. I give it 8 of 8 slices! The place is famous and rightfully so as you said, they must be doing something right being that they have been around since 1929! And it is always packed. I live in the area and constantly frequent the place. Its the best pizza in New York! And by the way, you spelled Bleecker wrong!!!