Posted By: Pizza Expert on February 17th, 2009
Went with Joe to get some Italian food and ended up at a place called O Sole Mio Pizza in Stony Brook. Even though we went to get pasta, I had to try a slice for an appetizer.
I gotta tell you, my previous experiences at this place have been much better then tonight. Maybe it was because it was a corner slice and since we split the slice in half, I got stuck with the crust and little pizza? But the sauce tasted very off tonight.
In the past Sole Mio (which also owns other pizza places locally) has had a really delicious slice, with crispy crust and soft inside. Just didn’t get that vibe tonight. The crust was almost like over cooked and was hard to bite into. Once I finally did bite into the slice it was tough to chew. The cheese tasted great, but I am thinking they used some old dough to cook this sliced pie, and had it sitting out on the counter for too long. I will definitely go back to this place, since I cannot let one bad experience out of many good experiences ruin my taste for O Sole Mio.
I will give O Sole Mio 4 out of 8 slices for this visit.
Also: This place has a website that is totally awful as well. Why does every place I eat at seem to think they can attract business with websites that a 9 year old could build better. Please contact me for a redesign…you need it!