review

World Pie Pizza Bridgehampton New York

This is a review that has 2 sides of the story.  When driving through the lovely Bridgehampton in Long Island, you can not help but notice a lovely storefront with a majestic gold leaf sign that says “World Pie“.  I love the name the building and the sign.  I have wanted to go to this […]

4 / 8
Slice Rating

World Pie Pizza Bridgehampton New York

Posted By: Big G
View site

World PizzaWorld Pizza SliceThis is a review that has 2 sides of the story.  When driving through the lovely Bridgehampton in Long Island, you can not help but notice a lovely storefront with a majestic gold leaf sign that says “World Pie“.  I love the name the building and the sign.  I have wanted to go to this place for months and finally I talked my wife into going with me.

The wonderful young girl who greeted us was a pleasant and speedy worker that should give classes to others who want to be exceptional in food services.  They brought us a basket of mixed breads.  Apple, blueberry, cinnamon desert like treats,  I liked the moist Apple bread best of all.  We ordered a Regular pizza that I asked for light basil.  (See picture)  The Pizza cook had a stack of half cooked doughs stacked 2 feet high.  I thought that should give it a nice crispy crust with a double bake.  The pizza came shortly after the Mrs. ate her salad that she loved, and the moment of truth came when I tasted my first bite.  I felt like Ralphy in Christmas story when he did not get the red rider BB gun, and instead got a pink pajama outfit that made him look like a ridiculous rabbit.

This is what I waited months to try?  This bland, dead, lifeless pizza that took time and effort to make from scratch.  If I were a hospital owner I would contract this place to make food for the elderly patients.  The dough even double cooked was soggy thin and tasteless.  The sauce was like a supermarket bought tomato sauce from a can, and the cheese was more for looks then taste.

Here is the second part I earlier told you about.  My wife loved it.  Thanks to her bad taste she did pick me, so at least we know she is consistent.  I told her I would mention that she would have given this disgraceful pizza a 6 out of 8 slices but as I informed her, she does not write for WorstPizza.  I love her, but I hate her opinion on this pizza place with the great name and look, yet manged to drop the ball on the actual Pizza.  I will go there again but I will get something else.  I will also eat some more of that apple bread.

4 of 8 slices and I think I gave one slice just for the name.

  • make an
    order
    (631) 537-7999

  • 2402 Montauk Hwy Bridgehampton, NY 11932

Leave a Reply

  • *
  • *

7 Responses to “World Pie Pizza Bridgehampton New York”

  • poodis pie wrote:
    22 Jan 2009 at 2:31 pm

    world pie is great… maybe instead of getting a plain pizza you should get a little more adventure in your like. you r wife is smart.. you are a duche

  • West Hamp Hank wrote:
    01 Feb 2009 at 5:54 pm

    Wow…that poodis pie is an asshole. Must live in Bridge. Also, she is a moron who cannot spell..so she must be an expert. I think I saw her and all the other Blue Collar Einsteins at Colosseo Pizza in PJS eating that swill they call pizza.
    I agree with your review on World Pie. Right on the money.
    $17 for a small pie and $20 for a large. The small is the size of a paper plate and compared to Ellio's..choose Ellio's. The salads are great..desserts are local and awesome but this is a pizza blog..and they blow.
    Crust has always been undercooked. they use a nice quality cheese but the sauce is non-existent.

  • West Hamp Hank wrote:
    02 Feb 2009 at 12:54 am

    Wow…that poodis pie is an asshole. Must live in Bridge. Also, she is a moron who cannot spell..so she must be an expert. I think I saw her and all the other Blue Collar Einsteins at Colosseo Pizza in PJS eating that swill they call pizza.
    I agree with your review on World Pie. Right on the money.
    $17 for a small pie and $20 for a large. The small is the size of a paper plate and compared to Ellio's..choose Ellio's. The salads are great..desserts are local and awesome but this is a pizza blog..and they blow.
    Crust has always been undercooked. they use a nice quality cheese but the sauce is non-existent.

  • Dishing on Dining wrote:
    13 Jul 2010 at 5:25 pm

    I live in Water Mill and have gone to World Pie for a few times now. Food is great but service SUCKS! Haven't had a single good dining experience. The waitstaff is rude and the managers don't help. I'd recommend take out.

  • Tara wrote:
    13 Jul 2010 at 5:28 pm

    I live in Water Mill and have gone to World Pie for a few times now. Food is great but service SUCKS! Haven't had a single good dining experience. The waitstaff is rude and the managers don't help. I'd recommend take out.

  • Dishing on Dining wrote:
    13 Jul 2010 at 5:28 pm

    Blah

  • hamptonz wrote:
    12 May 2012 at 6:58 pm

    World Pie has some of the worst food I’ve ever had. Not only is it horrible, it’s ridiculously overpriced.

RECEIVE PIZZA REVIEWS