Nicky’s Pizza Restaurant White Plains New York

Posted By: Matt's Pizza on January 1st, 2009

This review of Nicky’s pizza is temporarily under review, although we may have not liked it, please go in and try it for yourself. In my personal opinion, Mario’s across the street is much more appetizing and would personally choose to go there.

Thanks

Post comment

Nicky's Pizza Restaurant White Plains Ne...

Address	91 Mamaroneck Ave White Plains, NY 10601
Phone	917-997-6951

Get Directions

Italiansub
I just ordered a sandwich from Nicky’s and had to let the world know about this pathetic enterprise. I ordered the Italian combo, which is listed on the menu at about $9 – a little pricey, but people in my office rave about the pizza, so I went ahead. The woman behind the counter asked whether I wanted lettuce/tomato, onions, oil/vinegar, or anything else on it. I didn’t even stop to think…I said, Sure, I’ll have everything with hot peppers. She called the order in, punched her cash register, and handed me a check for $13.46. Huh? Turns out that THEY CHARGE FOR LETTUCE AND FOR TOMATO AND FOR OIL AND FOR VINEGAR…$0.50 per item. Thirteen and half bucks for an Italian combo!?!? OK, this is the most I’ve ever paid for a sandwich I’ve ordered everywhere, but let’s give it a shot…maybe it will be the best ever. I give her a twenty, she hands back $6.50. OK, it’s only four cents short, that ain’t gonna change my life, but at least ask me, ya know? Ten minutes later, out comes my wrapped sandwich. I thank her and head back to the office. And here comes the clincher. No, it’s not that the three tomato slices were so thin that I could see through them. No, it’s not that the sandwich had maybe one-quarter pound of tasteless cold cuts on it. It’s this: IT WAS SLATHERED IN MAYONNAISE! What self-respecting Italian puts mayo on an Italian combo? I’m stunned, and after scraping away the mayo, and therefore most of the bread, and then finshing this pathetic excuse for a sandwich, I’m hungry. So the moral of the story: stick to the pizza.
that guy
don't bother with this hell hole. I don't know why anyone would go there. I didn't like there pizza when i was a kid and i had no taste for anything. kids eat elios and i thought this was bad. Go across the street to Mario's.
Brad
You, sir, have no idea what you are talking about. But the fact that you are an idiot is not surprising, since you admitted you grew up in a landfill with its own zip code.
Nicky's is delicious. I have had pizza all over the country, and maybe Nicky's isn't the best of all of them, but it is far bettter than most. Maybe you had a bad experience, and that sucks, but try it again sometime. Nicky's is very good.
mattspizza
Nicky's sucks, and if you like it, you have no idea what your talking about. Ha Ha, there's a garbage dump in Staten Island. You got me. Name one place Nicky's is better than. See, you can't.
kg
The best PIZZA in White Plains!!!
J Howard
Agreed it was $4.00 for a cheese slice and I can tell you that the cheese was processed and the sauce was so full of sugar or whatever they added that it was gross…
My first warning should have been the guido in front hawking slices and trying to get you into his establishment.
There are far far better places in White Plains and this one should change its name to “SPACE FOR LEASE”
The only redeeming quality was the fact that I only ordered one slice. They are truly a place that should go down in your hall of fame as Worst Slice in the NY Metro area……
J Howard
Agreed it was $4.00 for a cheese slice and I can tell you that the cheese was processed and the sauce was so full of sugar or whatever they added that it was gross…
My first warning should have been the guido in front hawking slices and trying to get you into his establishment.
There are far far better places in White Plains and this one should change its name to “SPACE FOR LEASE”
The only redeeming quality was the fact that I only ordered one slice. They are truly a place that should go down in your hall of fame as Worst Slice in the NY Metro area……
R.Rios
born and raised in white plains, Nicky’s is the worst of them all. expensive and rude employees/owner. No sense of building rapport, just wants as much money as they can get from you. the one thing i can remember Nicky’s for is there sicilian pizza, Huge! Other than that, you better off going across the street to mario’s or down the street to Italian pavilion
pizzanpasta.
There are tons of pizzarias in White plains, but not many are good. Mario’s pizza is really weak. I have lived in white plains my whole life and Nicky’s is one of the better slices. Italian Pavilion is also amazing. Other than that, good slices are few and very far between.
pizzanpasta
agreed the owners and staff aren’t the friendliest at all, sometimes I feel uncomfy, thats why i just do delivery lol. pizza isnt bad at all tho.
Anonymous
I agree, it was surprising how bad the pizza in Westchester is when everyone raves about “New York” pizza

Nicky’s Pizza Restaurant White Plains New York

Related Post

Nicky's Pizza Restaurant White Plains Ne...

Subscribe

Recent Tweets

Our Friends