Carnival Restaurant Pizza Port Jefferson Station Long Island

1/ 8
Slice Rating

Carnival Restaurant Pizza Port Jefferson Station Long Island

Posted By: Pizza Expert
View site

- Pizzeria in Port Jefferson Station the day of my departure back to Florida.  She said although the place was pretty expensive, I was worth it.  So we headed to this dreary looking shopping center out in Port Jefferson Station and tried Carnival Pizza.

Even though they have a pizza counter to order slices from, we chose to sit in the restaurant and relax, since my mother and father were there also.  I ordered just one Sicilian slice since I was not too hungry.  After waiting what could have been 20 minutes for the slice, it finally arrived after I mentioned something to waitress.  Here is just another fine example why the only thing a server can do to pizza, is ruin it.  Carnival Pizza certainly has a circus style of service!

The pizza itself was a little cold, since it most likely had been sitting on the counter waiting for the the waitress to have to go and get it. I am aware this was my fault, since I could have eaten at the counter.  The slice actually tasted ok, and my favorite aspect was how ultra soft the inside of the crust was compared to the outside.  The pizza did not lack on quality, just lacked on the delivery.  If my overall experice was better I might have given this place a higher rating.  I will give Carnival Pizza in Port Jefferson 5 out of 8 slices.  Next time I am in town I will give the counter a try and see if it tastes better fresh from the oven.

  • make an

Leave a Reply

  • *
  • *

11 Responses to “Carnival Restaurant Pizza Port Jefferson Station Long Island”

  • Sandy wrote:
    27 Sep 2008 at 11:59 am

    Carnival pizza, is the best. I don't eat pizza crust and I even ate that! I had chicken cutlet pieces put ontop of my pizza, and it was the freshest cutlets ever! It was a bit cold, cheese not all the way melted, but I wll give this pizzaria 7 slices ou of 8.

  • Pizza Nazzi wrote:
    14 Nov 2008 at 1:38 pm

    That place sucks. The service is one of the worst in the area and the pizza is just slightly better than that crap they serve at Colesso Pizza in Port Jeff Station. There are a few pizza reviews on about these wonderful establishments.
    Good Stuff!

  • Mike wrote:
    30 Nov 2008 at 10:18 pm

    I am a regular at Carnival Restaurant and the service there is amazing. They treat me like I'm VIP, call me by first name, and they are very generous when it comes to serving size. If I don't like something that they gave me they give 2 of something i do like. The only thing is a lot of people go there and you have to listen for your ticket # to be called to get your food. That's when it is really crowded.

  • Brian M wrote:
    09 Dec 2008 at 3:05 pm

    wow..they call you by your first name…that's impressive. I guess you understand Spanish?
    The waitresses that work there are very unskilled but I do like the pasta. Top of the list. I agree with the comment above yours about the pizza. I don't like it or that obnoxious tough guy with the tattoos that refuses to smile. The Wine dinners are fun.

  • lectureguy wrote:
    24 Aug 2009 at 1:31 pm

    The Crap at Collosseo??? what the heck are you talking about? That pizza is wonderful. THE BEST!

  • lectureguy wrote:
    24 Aug 2009 at 8:31 pm

    The Crap at Collosseo??? what the heck are you talking about? That pizza is wonderful. THE BEST!

  • coach andrea wrote:
    18 Feb 2010 at 9:56 pm

    Today 2 friends who hadn't been into Carnival for quite a while decided to give it another try; we won't be back. Our server was not interested in being a server once our food was on our table: never asked to refill a soda, didn't offer to refill water. My Caesar's Salad came without dressing and without croutons. When I asked for dressing she disappeared, never to return. Finally, when we were ready to go and the bus girl came by, I asked her to take the salad off the bill as it was uneaten; even that didn't prompt a visit from the waitress. She dropped the bill on the table, said not a word. When I asked her why she wasn't interested in asking about the non-billed salad her remark was 'what should I have done, fight with you over it?' No, what she should have done is apologize, or offer a replacement, or offer to take it off the bill or just delivered the dressing as asked. But I guess she forgot that she serves diners, not food. Yup – this helped us remember why we hadn't been in for so long!

  • Union TuFF wrote:
    19 Feb 2010 at 12:50 pm

    you a Moron people like you think the Olive Garden is good.. Carnival Pizza is one of the best on Long island blows Colosseo out of the water… no wonder why poppa jon and all that other crap is on T.V addddss all over you people make me SICKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK…

  • Mallory Wood wrote:
    17 Apr 2010 at 10:26 am

    I grew up on Nicky's pizza. Sitting on the stool sipping a soda eating a slice. What memories. I loved that shopping center,….great memories. There is no other pizza like Pizza Carnival, especially down here in South Florida. 🙁

  • Mad4minpins wrote:
    11 Mar 2011 at 1:35 am

    Carnival pizza has to be the absolute WORST pizza on Long Island. For a brief moment while I bit into my tasteless slice of regular pizza I imagined I was in Pennsylvania eating what I thought was the worst slice of pizza I had ever eaten then I realized no I am on long island eating the worst slice of New York Pizza I have ever eaten! If you think this place is good then you most likely smoke lots of crack on a daily basis! The cheese was dry and conjealed like an old scab. I asked for it to be just warm but of course it was piping hot. I loaded it up with parmasean cheese and garlic salt and to no avail I ended up biting into a dead floppy tasteless fish of a pizza slice! With each bite it got worse and worse. If you want REAL pizza take a road trip down to Umbertos behind the Smithhaven Mall!

  • Pizzapolice wrote:
    20 Aug 2013 at 8:35 am

    Ok if you like Carnival Pizza then I’m sorry to say but I have no respect for you as a pizza “expert”. I have tried many of the pizza places you’ve reviewed here on your blog and I would rate carnival pizza right up there with Pizza Hut and Domino’s! It’s by far the worst pizza I’ve ever tried! I’ve had better pizza in Pennsylvania and North Carolina which are two states not known for great pizza! Ewwww